43 Star Island Drive, Miami Beach, FL 33139 (MLS# A11676770)

$36,000,000

43 Star Island Drive
Miami Beach, FL 33139
MLS# A11676770
Status: Closed
8 beds | 11 baths | 11104 sqft

1 / 1

Property Description
A generational opportunity to purchase on Miami Beach's most coveted guard-gated Star Island. This meticulously curated 11K+ SF private compound is set on over an acre of lush foliage, w/ 200 ft of prime WF w/captivating Bay & skyline views. Upon entry to the double height foyer, you will find numerous entertaining areas throughout the residence. The expansive gourmet kitchen, outfitted w/Viking, SubZero & Miele appliances w/oversized island & breakfast room flows effortlessly into the elegant dining room. All bedrooms are ensuite & generously sized. Additional highlights include a bar, office, upstairs kitchen & family room, workshop, rooftop terrace, 2 separate guest houses, boathouse, & more. Seize this rare opportunity to claim a legacy estate on this exclusive island sanctuary!

Details

Maps

Documents

Contract Information

Comp Sale YN: No

Occupant Type: Call Listing Agent

Listing Date: 2024-11-01

Status: Closed

Original List Price: 54000000

Sold Price: $36,000,000

Current Price: $36,000,000

Location and Legal

County Or Parish: Miami-Dade

County Parish Name: Miami-Dade

City Name: Miami Beach

Municipal Code: 2

Postal Zip: 33139

Development Name: STAR ISLAND

Subdivision Number: 1

Flood Zone: AE

Country: United States

Street Number: 43

Street Name: Star Island

Street Suffix: Drive

State Or Province: FL

Postal Code: 33139

Postal Code +4: 5146

Subdivision Name: CORRECTED PL OF STAR ISLA

Area: 2420

Elementary School: Miami Beach South Pointe

Middle Or Junior School: Miami Beach Nautilus

High School: Miami Beach

Parcel Number: 0242040010360

Zoning: 2200

General Property Information

Adjusted Area Main: 10109

Living Area Main: 11104

Attached Carport YN: No

Lot Size Area: 48266

Water Frontage Feet: 203

Senior Community YN: No

Outdoor Living Spaces YN: Yes

Stories Total: 2

Fireplace YN: Yes

Pool Private YN: Yes

Spa YN: Yes

Guest House YN: Yes

Property Sub Type: Single Family Residence

Bedrooms Total: 8

Bathrooms Total: 11

Bathrooms Full: 8

Bathrooms Half: 3

Building Area Main: 11104

Year Built: 1923

Garage YN: 1

Garage Spaces: 3

Carport YN: 1

Carport Spaces: 6

Covered Spaces: 9

Lot Size Acres: 1.11

Waterfront YN: 1

Direction Faces: Southeast

Financial Information

Association Membership: Voluntary

Membership Fee Required YN: No

Association YN: 1

Tax Annual Amount: 295147

Tax Year: 2024

Tax Legal Description: STAR ISLAND CORR PL PB 31-60 LOT 43 LOT SIZE 48266 SQ FT OR 26132-4385 07 2007 5

Office/Member Information

DXORIGMLSID: SEF

Status Change Information

Buyer Financing: Cash

Major Change Timestamp: 2025-08-21T14:11:09Z

Major Change Type: Status Change

Price Change Timestamp: 2025-03-05T21:29:17Z

Status Change Date: 2025-08-22

Under Contract Date: 2025-06-11

Close Date: 2025-08-21

Close Price: 36000000

Association Amenities

Gated: 1

Security: 1

Dining Area

Breakfast Area: 1

Eat-In Kitchen: 1

Formal Dining: 1

Exterior Features

Awning(s): 1

Barbecue: 1

Built-in Barbecue: 1

Lighting: 1

Flooring

Marble: 1

Wood: 1

Guest House Features

1 Bedrooms: 1

2 Baths: 1

Kitchen: 1

Living Room: 1

Parking Features

Covered: 1

Driveway: 1

Electric Vehicle Charging Station(s): 1

Golf Cart Garage: 1

Carport: 1

Detached Carport: 1

Spa Features

In Ground: 1

Fencing

Fenced: 1

Other Structures

Outbuilding: 1

Possession

Negotiable: 1

Sewer

Public Sewer: 1

View

Water: 1

Heating

Central: 1

Water Access

Ocean Access: 1

Water View

Bay: 1

Window Features

Blinds: 1

Appliances

Dishwasher: 1

Dryer: 1

Gas Range: 1

Microwave: 1

Oven: 1

Refrigerator: 1

Washer: 1

Construction Materials

CBS: 1

Interior Features

Bar: 1

Built-in Features: 1

Closet Cabinetry: 1

Elevator: 1

Entrance Foyer: 1

Kitchen Island: 1

Walk-In Closet(s): 1

Wet Bar: 1

Levels

Two: 1

Listing Terms

Cash: 1

Conventional: 1

Pool Features

In Ground: 1

Roof

Barrel: 1

Security Features

Security Patrol: 1

Water Source

Public: 1

Waterfront Features

Bayfront: 1

Seawall: 1

No Fixed Bridges: 1

Water Heater Details

Gas Water Heater: 1

Boat and Dock Information

Dock: Yes

Boat and Dock Features

Lift: 1

Private Dock: 1

Cooling

Central Air: 1

Showing Requirements

Call Listing Agent: 1

Master Bedroom/Bath

Dual Sinks: 1

Master Bdrm - Sitting: 1

Master Bdrm - Upstairs: 1

Separate Shower: 1

Separate Tub: 1

Pool Size Details

Pool Size (WxL): 0

Restrictions

Other Restrictions: 1

Storm Protection

Impact Glass: Complete

Permanent Generator: Whole House

Outdoor Living Spaces

Balcony: 1

Balcony Details

Balcony - Open: 1

Contingencies

None: 1

Room Types

Den: 1

Family Room: 1

Laundry: 1

Maid/In-Law Quarters: 1

Media Room: 1

Workshop: 1

Buyer Details

Intended Use: Unknown/Withheld

Concessions

Seller Concessions: No

Section Details

Parcel Number MLX: 0360

Acreage Description

1 To Less Than 2 Acre Lot: 1

Originating Details

Originating System Key: 402121548

Originating System ID: M00000151

Property Features

Association Amenities: Gated; Security

Dining Area: Breakfast Area; Eat-In Kitchen; Formal Dining

Exterior Features: Awning(s); Barbecue; Built-in Barbecue; Lighting

Flooring: Marble; Wood

Guest House Features: 1 Bedrooms; 2 Baths; Kitchen; Living Room

Parking Features: Covered; Driveway; Electric Vehicle Charging Station(s); Golf Cart Garage; Carport; Detached Carport

Spa Features: In Ground

Appliances: Dishwasher; Dryer; Gas Range; Microwave; Oven; Refrigerator; Washer

Water Heater Details: Gas Water Heater

Boat and Dock Features: Lift; Private Dock

Construction Materials: CBS

Cooling: Central Air

Fencing: Fenced

Heating: Central

Interior Features: Bar; Built-in Features; Closet Cabinetry; Elevator; Entrance Foyer; Kitchen Island; Walk-In Closet(s); Wet Bar

Levels: Two

Listing Terms: Cash; Conventional

Other Structures: Outbuilding

Pool Features: In Ground

Possession: Negotiable

Restrictions: Other Restrictions

Roof: Barrel

Security Features: Security Patrol

Sewer: Public Sewer

View: Water

Water Access: Ocean Access

Water Source: Public

Water View: Bay

Waterfront Features: Bayfront; Seawall; No Fixed Bridges

Window Features: Blinds

Showing Requirements: Call Listing Agent

Outdoor Living Spaces: Balcony

Balcony Details: Balcony - Open

Contingencies: None

Room Types: Den; Family Room; Laundry; Maid/In-Law Quarters; Media Room; Workshop

Acreage Description: 1 To Less Than 2 Acre Lot

Room Information

Room Name

Den

Family Room

Maid/In-Law Quarters

Media Room

Laundry

Workshop

Client Testimonials

Click Here To Leave A Review

Carolyn from the very beginning was professional and very knowledgeable about the area and where to begin the process. Getting all the information together for myself and three out of state siblings was a feat in itself. She definitely took the time and laid out the process and the best course for us to sell quickly, and we did. I have and will recommend her to everyone looking to sell or buy in the area. I look forward to working with again when needed.

Great experience working with Carolyn. She was my advocate throughout the buying process. Her professionalism, courtesy and proactive approach made everything go smoothly. I would highly recommend her expertise.

Carolyn was an immense help in selling our house. She is patient, kind and went out of her way to make the sale of our house possible. Would recommend this competent realtor.

Carolyn was excellent! She showed the house several times and we were in the middle of COVID, she was respectful of both our needs and the potential buyers needs. She was very persistent in getting finding a buyer for us and it was sold in a manner of just a few months!

Carolyn was a pleasure to work with. I took all her advice and she was 100% correct on all her ideas and suggestions. She is extremely responsive to calls & texts. If I were to buy in this area I would use her, and if you are going to sell your home, you should use her.

In such a challenging market, Kristen was very strategic and patient as we searched and searched for the perfect home for our family. She was very thorough, professional while still personal to our needs. Kristen always made herself available. She made the process easy and I would use and recommend her many times over.

Kristen is an amazing realtor. She was there for us from initial listing to closure. Answering questions, resolving issues and guiding us through all the intricacies of the real estate world. She is a true professional and someone we unreservedly recommend.

I had a great experience buying with Carolyn, she went above and beyond to provide me with excellent service. Even after an issue at closing was adamant about helping and protecting my interests.

Kristen Remling was a tremendous asset in the sale of my home. The house went under contract the first day of the listing. They marketed the property beautifully. The contract was solid, and everything went smoothly right through closing. I would recommend Kristen and the MacEvoy Team to anyone looking to buy or sell a home.

Best Realtor!! very professional understanding, caring.

Carolyn was great to work with. We were out of state sellers so Carolyn had to be at the property not just for potential buyers but also for coordinating fix ups, clean ups, meeting contractors and follow ups. She did this all smoothly and professionally. I'd happily work with her again.

5 STAR Responsiveness, 5 STAR Negotiation Skills, 5 STAR Professionalism & Communication, 5 STAR Market Expertise

Carolyn Mac Evoy was friendly, attentive to detail and professional. She handled all of the selling of my villa and handled any problems that came up. She made the sell easy. She protected my property as well. I will use Carolyn again. I recommend Carolyn.

Carolyn Mac Evoy was a charm to work with concerning my residencial property. She hit the nail right on the head with the property pricing. And, was able to bring the buyer along throughout the process. I highly recommend Ms. Mac Evoy for her expertise in the realty field and would hire her again and again.

Carolyn was very on time and informed on showing times, that way you could plan the day around a showing time.Also, very informative if you have a question that was a concern to the listing or closing. Thank you Carolyn Great job listing and selling my home.

Carolyn is as friendly as she is professional. She was in touch with me throughout the selling process, from the listing and pricing experience, through presenting offers, finally accepting an offer and then the closing activities. Couldn't ask for a better salesperson.

Carolyn listened to my needs and answered all my questions and concerns. She was always right on top of things, always friendly, and always helpful. She is now my trusted advisor and friend. I highly recommend her services for all your real estate needs. You won't be disappointed.

Carolyn was simply a great person to work with. Her knowledge and understanding of the real estate market was very comforting and her tenacity reassured us that she was the right person for the job. Without a doubt, I recommend her without any reservations.

Carolyn did a great job of advising me on the steps I should take to prepare the property before listing. She combined her knowledge of the market with almost 20 comparable properties to come up with the listing price and convinced me and (and the buyer) that the property should sell very close to the listing price, which it did. She was a good communicator and very responsive throughout the entire process.

Carolyn was a pleasure to work with. I was out of state and she kept me well informed and went the extra mile to prepare, show and sell my property. She helped me navigate the sale process and was very professional and personalable. Overall a great experience with Carolyn.

Carolyn MacEvoy is the EPITOME of real estate, she is extremely knowledgeable and most helpful in any situation! Carolyn goes above and beyond the call of duty, we had questions and she was amazingly already taking care of it. My husband and I not only found the BEST real estate agent but a wonderful friend too.

Carolyn was a joy to work with. She really knows the market and gave us informed advice always looking out for our best interests. I highly recommend her for anyone buying or selling property on the Treasure Coast.

She was always one text away morning noon or night Excellent personal service She was consistently positive She feared nothing Worked with me like a true business partner Ultimately sold my home with in the time frame.

Ms. MacEvoy worked with us through the entire process. She was professional, communicating every step of the way. Whenever a potential obstacle may appear, she was ahead of the game, not only alerting us of potential issues, but also providing solutions. Have recommended her to others and would use her again for any future real estate needs.

Carolyn did a great job in helping me find my home. She listened carefully to my wants and needs and, most importantly, price range. She was always very friendly and professional, and I would recommend her highly to anyone planning to buy or sell their home.

As we all know moving can be extremely stressful… Carolyn went above and beyond to make sure everything went smoothly even went as far as helping me in my move on Labor Day weekend…She truly caresand is there for you every step of the way… I highly recommend her!

My husband and I have been working with Carolyn for the past year. She is a consummate professional, with extensive knowledge of the market. She is personable and is always willing to go the extra mile for her clients. She is a pleasure to work with. I would wholeheartedly recommend her to anyone.

Very responsive and cooperative.

Knowledgeable, professional, personable. She sold our home in 6 weeks at fair market value in early 2019.

Carolyn worked so hard to make sure my townhouse sold even with the Coronavirus going on. She was on top of the showings, and followed up with other realtors. She gave me great feedback on the showings. I was an out of state owner, and Carolyn really went above and beyond to check in on the property during the listing. I would highly recommend her to sell your property.

This is a long overdue review. Last year, Carolyn Mac Evoy listed, and sold, a house for me in Vero Beach.... A dear friend recommended Carolyn - saying I could rely completely on her professional manner and skill. He was right. Carolyn came in, took photos , had house listing up that night . Sold that week.(...) For once in my life, I had the sense to take the advice of someone who knew exactly what to do. She is dedicated, professional and real estate is her passion. It shows. Just call her!